03 8622 8200
Work

Five things to ask a criminal lawyer before hiring them

1. Have You Handled a Case Like This Before?

When facing criminal charges, it is essential to seek advice from a criminal lawyer in Victoria with specific experience in cases that are similar to yours. Ask your lawyer directly if they’ve handled similar cases—because a legal professional who understands the nature of your charges, the potential penalties, and the best available strategies can significantly improve your chances of a favourable outcome.

You should engage a criminal defence lawyer as soon as you become aware that you're under investigation. An experienced lawyer familiar with Victoria’s criminal justice system will help you understand the investigative process and your rights, prepare for a police interview, assist with court preparation, and guide you in deciding whether to plead guilty or contest the charges.

At Stary Norton Halphen, our legal team practices exclusively in criminal law. We have experience across all Victorian courts— the Children’s Court, Magistrates’ Court, County Court, and Supreme Court. Many of our lawyers conduct their own advocacy, giving them a comprehensive understanding of the law, court procedures, and effective defence strategies.

2. How Will Engaging You Benefit My Case?

Before choosing a criminal lawyer, it’s important to understand how their representation will impact your case. One of the core duties of any lawyer is to act in their client’s best interests. The way they answer this question can reveal how well they understand your legal issue and whether they’re committed to helping you achieve the best possible result.

An experienced criminal lawyer will:

  • Explain the legal process and what to expect in court;
  • Help you understand the charges and determine whether you have a viable defence;
  • Advise you of the potential outcomes—whether you plead guilty or are found guilty after contesting;
  • Follow your instructions closely and work toward the best possible result based on the evidence in your case.

3. What Can I Do to Help Myself?

At Stary Norton Halphen, we recognise that being charged with a criminal offence can be one of the most distressing experiences of your life. However, it can also mark a turning point. We often advise clients on steps they can take to assist their case and, in many instances, promote their personal wellbeing, such as:

  • Accessing counselling or emotional support to manage the stress of facing charges; and
  • Seeking treatment for underlying issues like mental health conditions or substance use disorders.

As criminal lawyers, we frequently refer clients to relevant support services because proactive rehabilitation can not only improve your situation personally but also positively influence your outcome in court. If you choose to plead guilty, documented evidence of rehabilitation—such as medical or counselling reports—can result in a favourable assessment of your prospects and more lenient sentence.

A good lawyer will help you understand what steps you can take to support your case. Always ask how you can help yourself—your efforts can make a real difference.

4. What Kind of Legal Work Will You Do for Me?

Understanding what your criminal lawyer will do behind the scenes is crucial. Legal representation involves much more than just appearing in court. Skilled lawyers will walk you through their process so you can be confident in their expertise.

At Stary Norton Halphen, once you engage us:

  • We will obtain your brief of evidence from Victoria Police or another prosecuting authority (such as the AFP, WorkSafe, RSPCA, or your local council);
  • We will analyse all relevant evidence, including charge sheets, witness statements, interviews, CCTV footage, and photographs;
  • Based on our review, we will clearly explain your legal options and help you decide how to proceed, following which;
  • We will obtain your instructions and act in accordance with them.

If you choose to plead guilty, we will begin preparing your plea hearing immediately. This may involve gathering character references, medical or psychological reports, treatment program results, and any other information relevant to your case.

Being thoroughly prepared for court is critical to protecting your rights and securing the best possible result.

If you choose to plead not guilty, we will begin by preparing to run your defence in court. How we do this will vary from case to case. In some cases, we will seek additional material form the police and in others we will refrain from doing so. In some cases, we will seek the opinion of an expert and in others we will refrain from doing so. Each case is different and requires a strategic and well-conceived approach to maximise your prospects of success and secure the best possible result.

5. What’s the Difference Between a Criminal Lawyer and a Barrister?

A criminal lawyer (also known as a solicitor) works at a law firm and manages your case from beginning to end. They are usually your primary contact and may also appear in court appearing as an advocate on your behalf.

A criminal barrister, is a lawyer acting independently of the firm who is part of an association of other independent lawyers formally knowns as the Victorian Bar.

At Stary Norton Halphen, we collaborate with a wide range of barristers, particularly in jury trials and contested committal hearings, with expertise in areas including:

  • Drug offences
  • Sexual offences
  • White-collar crime
  • Homicide and serious violent crimes

At Stary Norton Halphen our lawyers are experienced advocates, commonly appearing in trials and other complex contested hearings, like many barristers do. So, if your case reaches a trial or complex hearing, we ensure you are represented by an appropriately skilled and experienced advocate, whether that is a barrister or lawyer.

Why Choose Stary Norton Halphen?

  • Decades of experience in criminal defence
  • Experienced Accredited Criminal Law Specialists
  • Representation in all Victorian courts
  • Trusted advocates with a client-first approach
  • Strategic and focused on achieving the best possible outcome having regard to the facts of your case

If you are facing criminal charges, don't wait—contact Stary Norton Halphen today for expert legal advice and the dedicated defence you deserve.

Five things to ask a criminal lawyer before hiring them