Case Studies
Explore case studies from Stary Norton Halphen & Galbally highlighting successful outcomes in criminal defence and high-profile criminal cases.
Learn how our Melbourne criminal lawyers approach challenging legal matters with strategic advocacy and experience.
Preserving Community-Based Sentence Following Further Family Violence Offending
Our client avoided further imprisonment after re-offending while serving a Community Correction Order, with the Court allowing him to continue his existing order.
Success Confirming a Diversion in Doubt
Jasper MacCuspie successfully preserved a client's Diversion, resulting in the original charge being dismissed and avoiding a criminal record.
Favourable Resolution of Contested Family Violence Intervention Order Proceeding
Lucy Massouras secured a favourable resolution for a Respondent in a contested Family Violence Intervention Order proceeding.
Withdrawal of Head Family Violence Charge and Non-Conviction Outcome
Lucy Massouras secured withdrawal of the principal family violence charge and a non-conviction outcome for a client facing serious allegations.
Securing Immediate Release Following County Court Plea for Drug Cultivation Offences
Lucy Massouras secured the immediate release of a client following a County Court plea for drug cultivation offences.
Successfully Securing Bail in Serious Terrorism-Related Offences Matter
Lucy Massouras successfully secured bail for a young client facing serious terrorism-related charges, despite prosecution opposition.
Mental Impairment Defence – Not Guilty by Reason of Mental Impairment
Jim McGarvie acted for a client charged with false imprisonment who was found not guilty by reason of mental impairment following a forensic psychiatric assessment.
Domestic Violence Charges Withdrawn After CCTV Evidence
Jim McGarvie acted for a client facing domestic violence charges after allegations made by her male partner. CCTV evidence ultimately led to all charges being withdrawn.
Successful Firearms Act Application – Client Deemed a Non-Prohibited Person
Alana Reader successfully acted for a client in a s 189 Firearms Act 1996 application, resulting in the client being deemed a non-prohibited person and able to re-apply for a firearms licence.
Acquittal at Trial in Attempted Home Invasion Matter
Stary Norton Halphen & Galbally secured an acquittal at trial for a young migrant charged with attempted home invasion after successfully challenging the prosecution’s identification evidence.
Averted Affray Prosecution Through Self-Defence Analysis
An 18-year-old client charged with affray and unlawful assault following a public altercation avoided prosecution entirely after detailed analysis of CCTV, witness statements, and interview material supported a viable self-defence argument. All charges were ultimately withdrawn, leaving the client with no criminal record.
Mercy for a Vulnerable Woman Facing Jail Time
A vulnerable woman with significant health issues and an extensive criminal history faced a serious risk of imprisonment after pleading guilty to shop theft charges. Through a detailed plea emphasising rehabilitation, stability, and medical vulnerability, the Court imposed a therapeutic community-based order instead of a custodial sentence.
Young People and Sexual Offending
Charged with grooming offences involving a child, our client faced a strong prosecution case and proceeded to a plea. By demonstrating a clear disparity in culpability between our client and a co-accused, we successfully secured a non-custodial sentence and avoided conviction.
Cultivating Cannabis in a Commercial Quantity
Charged with cultivating almost three times the commercial quantity of cannabis, our client faced mandatory imprisonment and had a relevant criminal history. With limited sentencing options available, the focus shifted to presenting the personal circumstances underpinning the offending and securing the best possible sentence structure, including an extended parole period.
All charges withdrawn following successful ID dispute
This case study demonstrates how a thorough review of evidence and strategic cross-examination led to the withdrawal of all charges against a client accused of a serious knife attack in Melbourne.
Trafficking in Commercial Quantity – Charges Withdrawn
This case study highlights how a client, initially facing serious commercial drug trafficking charges and mandatory jail time, avoided conviction through a strategic defence approach.
Early Rehabilitation and Targeted Defence Leads to Non-Custodial Outcome in Serious Offence
This case study describes how early intervention, psychological treatment, and a targeted defence strategy helped a young client facing serious charges avoid prison. By demonstrating rehabilitation and leveraging the client’s positive background, the legal team secured a plea deal and a non-custodial outcome.
Family Violence Defence Strategies
This case study examines a defence response to family violence allegations in Victoria. The client faced serious charges with significant legal and personal consequences. The defence strategy focused on challenging the credibility of the allegations, asserting self-defence where appropriate, and rigorously testing the prosecution’s evidence.
Successful Diversion from Criminal Charges for Client in Family Violence Incident
If you have been charged with a criminal offence, you may be eligible for the criminal justice diversion program. This pathway is available in the Magistrate's Court and provides a way to be ‘diverted’ away from the criminal jurisdiction.
CCO for Dangerous Driving Causing Death
Louise Conwell recently acted for a client charged with dangerous driving causing death. Our client was turning at an intersection when he struck a pedestrian and tragically killed her. The prosecution alleged that he failed to pay proper attention.
Disclaimer: The case studies on this page are provided for general information and educational purposes only. They describe particular matters and outcomes and are not intended to suggest that the same outcome will apply in another matter. Each legal matter depends on its own facts and circumstances.
Case studies do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice about your individual circumstances. To discuss your matter, please contact Stary Norton Halphen & Galbally.

