Case Studies
Explore case studies from Stary Norton Halphen & Galbally highlighting criminal matters defended by our lawyers across Melbourne and Victoria.
Our case studies provide examples of the matters we have acted in, including serious and complex criminal prosecutions, and illustrate the legal issues, strategies and outcomes involved in individual cases.
Successful Appeal Against a Personal Safety Intervention Order
Brett Barratt successfully appealed a personal safety intervention order in the County Court of Victoria. After a four-day contested hearing in the Magistrates’ Court, an order had been made against our client. The County Court allowed the appeal and set aside the Magistrates’ Court orders, meaning our client was no longer subject to the personal safety intervention order.
Client Facing Mandatory Jail Leaves Without a Conviction
Luke Metherell represented a young client facing a serious armed robbery allegation and other criminal matters. The matter ultimately resolved to a controlled weapon offence, with a fine imposed without conviction.
Plea Results in Community Correction Order for Client Living With Intellectual Disability
Luke Metherell secured a Community Correction Order for a client living with intellectual disability despite serious offending and a significant prior history.
Assault and Bail Breach Charges Withdrawn at Mention
Assault and bail breach charges were withdrawn at Mention following advocacy by Luke Metherell regarding the evidence and public interest.
Firearm Charge Withdrawn After Defence Challenges Alleged Firearm Component
A Prohibited Person Possess a Firearm charge was withdrawn at Mention following negotiations and written submissions by Luke Metherell.
Theft of Motor Vehicle Charge Withdrawn After Prosecution Case Challenged
Luke Metherell secured the withdrawal of a theft of motor vehicle charge at Contest Mention following persistent advocacy and negotiations with police.
All Charges Withdrawn Following High-Speed Police Chase
Luke Metherell acted for a passenger facing drug trafficking, cannabis possession and controlled weapon charges following a high-speed police pursuit. After the evidence was carefully assessed and the prosecution case was contested, all charges were withdrawn.
Severe Community Correction Order Dropped to Fine After County Court Appeal
Luke Metherell successfully appealed a stringent Community Correction Order in the County Court, securing a significantly reduced sentence of a $1,500 fine.
Diversion for Driving While Suspended
Luke Metherell secured diversion for a client charged with driving while suspended, resulting in no criminal record and only limited diversion conditions.
Drug Trafficking Plea Results in Fine Without Conviction
Our client faced a drug trafficking charge with strong prosecution evidence. Luke Metherell secured a fine without conviction, allowing her to continue her career.
Preserving Community-Based Sentence Following Further Family Violence Offending
Our client avoided further imprisonment after re-offending while serving a Community Correction Order, with the Court allowing him to continue his existing order.
Success Confirming a Diversion in Doubt
Jasper MacCuspie successfully preserved a client's Diversion, resulting in the original charge being dismissed and avoiding a criminal record.
Favourable Resolution of Contested Family Violence Intervention Order Proceeding
Lucy Massouras secured a favourable resolution for a Respondent in a contested Family Violence Intervention Order proceeding.
Withdrawal of Head Family Violence Charge and Non-Conviction Outcome
Lucy Massouras secured withdrawal of the principal family violence charge and a non-conviction outcome for a client facing serious allegations.
Securing Immediate Release Following County Court Plea for Drug Cultivation Offences
Lucy Massouras secured the immediate release of a client following a County Court plea for drug cultivation offences.
Successfully Securing Bail in Serious Terrorism-Related Offences Matter
Lucy Massouras successfully secured bail for a young client facing serious terrorism-related charges, despite prosecution opposition.
Mental Impairment Defence – Not Guilty by Reason of Mental Impairment
Jim McGarvie acted for a client charged with false imprisonment who was found not guilty by reason of mental impairment following a forensic psychiatric assessment.
Domestic Violence Charges Withdrawn After CCTV Evidence
Jim McGarvie acted for a client facing domestic violence charges after allegations made by her male partner. CCTV evidence ultimately led to all charges being withdrawn.
Successful Firearms Act Application – Client Deemed a Non-Prohibited Person
Alana Reader successfully acted for a client in a s 189 Firearms Act 1996 application, resulting in the client being deemed a non-prohibited person and able to re-apply for a firearms licence.
Acquittal at Trial in Attempted Home Invasion Matter
Stary Norton Halphen & Galbally secured an acquittal at trial for a young migrant charged with attempted home invasion after successfully challenging the prosecution’s identification evidence.
Disclaimer: The case studies on this page are provided for general information and educational purposes only. They describe particular matters and outcomes and are not intended to suggest that the same outcome will apply in another matter. Each legal matter depends on its own facts and circumstances.
Case studies do not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as a substitute for advice about your individual circumstances. To discuss your matter, please contact Stary Norton Halphen & Galbally.

