Case Summary
Our client was a highly vulnerable older woman charged with multiple contraventions of a family violence intervention order (FVIO) protecting her former male partner.
She had no history of family violence offending and faced the prospect of a criminal conviction.
The Challenge
Although our client faced multiple allegations of breaching the intervention order, the circumstances surrounding the relationship were considerably more complex than they initially appeared.
The defence identified concerns that our client had been incorrectly identified as the predominant aggressor without proper consideration of the broader history of family violence in the relationship, including financial exploitation she had experienced perpetrated by her former partner.
The ongoing proceedings were also taking a significant toll on our client's wellbeing.
Our Strategy
Madeleine Ulbrick prepared to contest the charges, examining the broader history of the relationship and the circumstances surrounding the alleged contraventions.
However, given the significant impact of the proceedings on our client, she instructed Madeleine to seek a sentence indication under sections 60-61 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2009 (Vic).
The Magistrate initially indicated that an aggregate fine without conviction would be imposed. While this outcome was within range for the offence type, it did not take into account the financial abuse suffered, or our client's extremely limited financial means.
Madeleine sought leave to make further submissions, emphasising that the indicated penalty simply represented the upper limit, or “ceiling”, of the sentencing outcome under consideration, rather than the only available outcome, and that the Court retained power to impose a more lenient disposition, including dismissal of the charge without recording a conviction under section 76 Sentencing Act 1991 (Vic).
Although the Magistrate initially maintained the indication, the defence persisted in seeking leave to make further submissions.
The Magistrate ultimately allowed the application. Madeleine then made further submissions addressing our client's vulnerability, the complexity of the relationship and the financial abuse she had experienced.
Having considered those submissions, the Magistrate reconsidered the indication and dismissed the charges.
The Result
The court granted an unconditional dismissal of all charges.
Our client avoided a criminal conviction.
The Importance of Experienced Criminal Defence
This matter demonstrates the importance of looking beyond the immediate allegations and understanding the broader dynamics of family violence.
It also highlights the importance of ensuring a vulnerable client's circumstances are properly brought to the Court's attention and that sentencing outcomes are carefully examined, even where the initial indication may appear to offer limited options.
Disclaimer: The case results featured are real matters handled by our firm. However, every case is different and outcomes vary depending on a range of factors, including the specific facts, circumstances and evidence involved. Past results are not a guarantee of future outcomes and should not be relied upon to predict or determine the result of your matter.

